Process
Status Items Highlights Done See section below Claims None Questions None Output None
Highlights
id1015890822
A database of poop images, collected from an AI poop analyzing app that he had launched several years ago. Basically, 25,000 people had been taking images of their poop and uploading them to his app. He’d been collecting, analyzing, and annotating these images and now wanted to sell access to them: “I’ve got 150k+ labeled and classified images of 💩 from roughly 25K different people. Jokes aside, I know there’s a lot of value in it (hard to obtain, useful for ML [machine learning] training, cancer studies etc) but not sure on how to move about it. Feels like I’m sitting on a pile of shi..ny coins but can’t find who wants them.”
✏️ He made an app to collect people’s poop images (offering “health” analysis for free), and now is ready to sell the data. Because this is the system as taught.
đź”— View Highlight
id1015890813
PoopCheck, an app made by a company called Soft All Things that purports to use AI to analyze images of one’s stool in order to give you a “daily gut health score.”
đź”— View Highlight
id1015890623
On the App Store page for PoopCheck, it says “The developer does not collect any data from this app.” The link to the privacy policy from within the App Store download page does not mention anything about selling or sharing the data and says “your health data is encrypted in transit and at rest. Photos are processed securely. We implement industry-standard security measures to protect your data.”Â
The PoopCheck website’s About page states “Privacy First.” And “Health data is sensitive. That’s why privacy isn’t a feature, it’s our foundation. Your photos are encrypted. You can delete everything at any time. We built PoopCheck the way we’d want our own health apps built.” The FAQ also notes “your privacy is our priority.”
✏️ So on the front-facing PR stuff, we can say whatever we want. Privacy first.
đź”— View Highlight
id1015890651
This is completely different from the “Service Agreement” and “Terms and Conditions” people agree to when they actually open the app and make an account. The Service Agreement states that “by uploading stool images or any health-related data to the App, you grant Soft All Things LLC a worldwide, irrevocable, perpetual, unconditional, royalty-free, fully-paid, transferable, sub licensable license to use, reproduce, modify, adapt, distribute, sell, license, and create derivative works from such content for any lawful purpose, including but not limited to research, commercial exploitation, product development, and third party licensing. You acknowledge that your images and data may be used to create, train, improve, and commercialize AI technologies and machine learning models, and that such models and any outputs derived from your data may be licensed or sold to third parties, including medical organizations, research institutions, and commercial partners.”
It adds that “your data may be irreversibly incorporated into AI models and aggregated datasets. Deletion of your account will remove your personal profile data but does not require the removal of anonymized, aggregated, or derivative data already processed or incorporated into AI models.” Under a section called “Sharing of Information,” it adds that the company reserves the right to share or sell the data “for any business purpose,” including “AI and Data Licensing.”
✏️ On the backend.. in the terms and conditions and service agreements we don’t read.. the truth comes out. Privacy last.. you give us permission and ownership of all our poop data to use as we see fit.
đź”— View Highlight
id1016719643
maybe should not be terribly surprising that a free app in which you upload images of your poop to a random company would have a business model focused on packaging and selling that data. But this type of data collection—of our literal poop—highlights how almost anything we do on our phones can ultimately end up for sale.
đź”— View Highlight